In today’s algorithm-driven world, it can feel like all the swiping and scrolling bleeds into having impersonal experiences. That’s where our 40-acre horse farm and bed & breakfast has bucked the trend; we provide a feeling of real hospitality. And thanks to our 476 TripAdvisor reviews, we have the data to prove it.
We ran every single TripAdvisor review through a sentiment analysis to uncover why we rank as one of the most beloved accommodations in the Hudson Valley. What we found wasn’t just nice words, but a portrait of something else; a place where our guests create memories that become part of their life’s story.
What Guests Talk About the Most (by the Numbers)
1. The Hostess (Maggie) – Mentioned 608 Times
“Maggie is an incredible host, who has created such a warm and inviting space”
“Maggie is the consummate host — striking the right balance between being available and giving guests their space.”
“Maggie is the most accommodating innkeeper ready to make your trip relaxing & enjoyable with perfectly appointed bedrooms & delicious breakfasts.”
2. The Farm – Mentioned 432 Times
“She has a beautiful farm, with horses and chickens and a 40 yr old mule. It is really enjoyable to walk outside to see them. It is very peaceful.”
“The property is beautiful—set on a horse farm where you can actually visit and spend time with her horses if you’d like, which was such a unique and peaceful touch.”
“If you love the smell of wild flowers and the charm and character of a well groomed farm then you will enjoy Whistle Wood.”
3. Breakfast – Mentioned 385 Times
“Delicious breakfasts with good conversation and farm-fresh eggs, with a wide variety of birds flitting back and forth from the nearby bird feeders.”
“She cooks up an incredible breakfast every morning with eggs made to order with herbs fresh from her garden, french toast, sausage, bacon, muffins, juice, coffee, tea – the works.”
“Maggie creates a lovely environment where you feel at home, whether it’s feeding the horses in the morning or tucking into one of her delicious treats for breakfast.”
4. Beauty – Mentioned 259 Times
“The property is beautiful—set on a horse farm where you can actually visit and spend time with her horses if you’d like, which was such a unique and peaceful touch.”
“Pictures do not capture the beauty of this bed and breakfast. Filled with tasteful furnishings and artistic flare, the inside is just as amazing as the grounds.”
“Our room was adorable and overlooked the farm. The farm is just beautiful.”
5. Rhinebeck – Mentioned 246 Times
“The farm is a few minutes drive from Rhinebeck, and so tranquil.”
“The house was clean, the bed was comfortable and breakfast and snack were delicious. Super close to downtown Rhinebeck.”
“The town of Rhinebeck is just a few mins away and it has shops, restaurants, etc. if you’d like a day away from the farm.”
6. Horses – Mentioned 236 Times
“You can take a walk around the property town to the pond, to visit the her horses which are complete beauties and so gentle…”
“The WhistleWood was a perfect spot for our group of 4 couples to gather and spend a few days together. The grounds & horses were beautiful…”
“We didn’t have time to feed the horses or the donkey so it seems we will have to return, if for no reason other than that.”
7. Home/Home-Like – Mentioned 207 Times
“Maggie is a phenomenal hostess and served up a wonderful breakfast every morning to get you started while making you feel at home.”
“Maggie makes us feel at home and cooks an amazing breakfast, always including eggs to each person’s individual taste.”
“Maggie creates a lovely environment where you feel at home, whether it’s feeding the horses in the morning or tucking into one of her delicious treats for breakfast.”
8. Fresh – Mentioned 189 Times
“I must also mention the breakfasts that Maggie makes every morning. She prepares them from farm fresh ingredients and you will not leave her table hungry.”
“Maggie prepared sumptuous ‘made to order’ breakfasts which included omelettes, yogurt, fresh fruit and fresh-baked muffins or biscuits every morning.”
“Maggie is a wonderful cook. Fresh breakfast daily and she is eager to please. A great deal of her ingredients came from her farm.”
9. Chickens – Mentioned 158 Times
“Loved petting her dogs, Pearl and Samantha and feeding the chickens and horses.”
“My husband and I just returned from a two night stay at Whistlewood… Being able to watch the horses, donkey, and chickens was a real treat!”
10. Eggs – Mentioned 145 Times
“She will make you made-to-order breakfast, with fresh eggs.”
“Breakfast consisted of so many different foods.”
“The morning breakfast was out of control. Extremely yummy eggs made to order, tasty bagels and english muffins, cereals, dollar pancakes, bacon, coffeecakes, juices, coffee, tea.”